The Best Cookie Presses – Two Peas & Their Pod

Share this post on:

I absolutely LOVE making LOTS of cookies every holiday season. Spritz cookies are a classic and always impress my family and friends. Not only are these buttery cookies delicious, but they’re also surprisingly easy to make. With one of the best cookie presses, you can quickly make a batch of these treats in festive shapes like trees, wreaths, ornaments, and more. 

spritz cookies.

A good spritz cookie press is the KEY to making these seasonal cookies, but some models are definitely easier to use than others.

Below, I’ve listed out the best cookie presses so you can make endless batches of tasty holiday cookies this year.

Our Top Picks

  1. Classic: Wilton Preferred Cookie Press – $25.69 at Amazon
  2. What’s in My Kitchen: OXO Good Grips Cookie Press – $33.99 at Amazon
  3. Best with Storage: Kukn Rikon Clear Cookie Press – $40.11 at Amazon
  4. Best Metal: Marcato Atlas Deluxe Cookie Press – $49.95 at Amazon

1. Wilton Preferred Cookie Press

Wilton Preferred
Credit: Amazon

Whenever I make spritz cookies, I reach for my Wilton Preferred Cookie Press. This inexpensive gadget always creates consistently perfect cookie shapes, and I LOVE its ergonomic and comfortable design. The trigger has a soft-coated grip, making it easy to press again and again (this is especially important since you’ll be using the press for EVERY cookie you make!). It’s so easy to use that even my kids can do it!

This cookie press has a metal base and plastic tube, and it comes with 12 disc shapes, including popular forms like a Christmas tree, wreath, snowman, pumpkin, turkey, heart, and more. I love that you’re not limited to holiday designs and can use different cute discs year-round. Wilton even sells additional cookie discs that fit this press perfectly for even more fun shapes.

The Specs:

  • Dimensions: 8.75 x 11 x 2.6 inches 
  • Body Material: Metal and plastic
  • Disc Material: Metal
  • Discs: 12

The Pros:

  • Easy to use
  • Durable metal body  
  • Ergonomic trigger
  • Clear dough barrel

The Cons:

  • Hand wash only
  • No disc storage

What Others are Saying: 

This Wilton cookie press has a 4.2-star rating from more than 6,000 Amazon reviews. Additionally, Food & Wine named it the best value cookie press.

Buy the Wilton Preferred Cookie Press: 

2. OXO Good Grips Cookie Press

OXO Good Grips
Credit: Wayfair

I’m a big fan of OXO Good Grips, and the brand’s cookie press seems just as easy to use as their other products. It works a bit differently than other presses — you actually rest the base directly on your baking sheet, then press down on the non-slip lever. The plunger will push out the perfect amount of dough, leaving behind a beautifully shaped cookie. It’s THAT easy! 

This cookie press has 12 discs, including a snowflake, wreath, heart, tree, bear, sunflower, and more. It also has a handy disc storage case, while the barrel, discs, and base are all dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning. 

The Specs:

  • Dimensions: 9 x 5.5 inches
  • Body Material: Plastic
  • Disc Material: Metal
  • Discs: 12

The Pros:

  • Fast, even results
  • Non-slip lever and base
  • Dishwasher-safe pieces
  • Includes disc storage case

The Cons:

  • May produce small cookies

What Others are Saying:

The OXO Good Grips Cookie Press has more than 8,700 reviews and a 4.4-star rating on Amazon. It was also named the best cookie press by both Food & Wine and The Spruce Eats.

Buy the OXO Good Grips Cookie Press: 

3. Kuhn Rikon Clear Cookie Press

Kuhn Rikon
Credit: Amazon

If you like to keep your baking supplies organized, the Kuhn Rikon Cookie Press is PERFECT. It comes with a handy storage case that holds both the cookie press gun and its attachments. 

You’ll also get 14 different discs for fun designs, including a variety of seasonal designs and a cheese straw disc. The set also comes with six piping tips that you can use for frosting desserts, as well as a variety of recipes for different spritz cookie flavors. 

This cookie press has a more basic design that you can operate with just one hand, making it a good pick for beginners. Just know that the barrel is a bit narrow, so you may have to refill it with dough more often. 

The Specs:

  • Dimensions: 8.5 x 2.75 inches
  • Body Material: Plastic and metal
  • Disc Material: Metal 
  • Discs: 16 + 6 piping tips

The Pros:

  • One-handed operation
  • Handy storage case 
  • Includes piping tips
  • Cheese straw disc

The Cons:

  • Hand wash recommended
  • Narrow barrel 

What Others are Saying:

Food & Wine named this model as the best cookie press with storage. 

Buy the Kuhn Rikon Clear Cookie Press: 

4. Marcato Atlas Deluxe Cookie Press

Marcato Atlas
Credit: Amazon

If you make spritz cookies ALL year long, the Marcato Atlas Deluxe Cookie Press has a durable all-metal design that can stand up to near-daily use. The whole press is made from aluminum, which is much sturdier than plastic. The brand even offers a 10-year warranty on it.

With this cookie press, you’ll get a whopping 20 different discs, offering you much more variety than other options on my list. It includes everything from trees and wreaths to hearts and shells, but it doesn’t come with a place to store it. I also LOVE the fun pink color it comes in, which is so cute!

The Specs:

  • Dimensions: 7.28 x 2.36 x 10.63 inches
  • Body Material: Aluminum
  • Disc Material: Aluminum
  • Discs: 20

The Pros:

  • Durable metal construction
  • Several colors available
  • Includes lots of discs
  • 10-year warranty

The Cons:

  • Hand wash only
  • No disc storage
  • Not everyone will love the pink hue

What Others are Saying:

This durable cookie press has a 4.5-star rating from more than 3,000 reviewers on Amazon.

Buy the Marcato Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker Cookie Press: 

King Arthur Spritz Cookie Press

King Arthur is another baking brand that I know and love. The spritz cookie press is made in Italy and constructed from durable metal. It comes with 20 cookie discs, and you can even adjust the knob at the top to change the cookie size. While it’s a good option, it’s a bit pricey when compared to similar metal models like the one from Marcato. The King Arthur Spritz Cookie Press is available at King Arthur for $99.95.

De Buyer Le Tube Pastry Press

If you want a tool that’s a bit more versatile in the kitchen, the Le Tube Pastry Press may be a good option. Its unique design is actually meant to replace pastry bags — it comes with plain and star tips for piping frosting, cream, and more. It also doubles as a cookie press and includes 13 discs for shapes like trees, hearts, and stars, and it’s safe to put in the microwave, freezer, and dishwasher. But because of its intricate design, there may be more of a learning curve for using it. It’s also way more expensive than other options on my list. The De Buyer Le Tube Pastry Press is available at Amazon for $135.

Fante’s Easy Cookie Press

For all the cheese straw lovers out there, this might be the best cookie press for you. The metal design of this Fante cookie press can make five classic Italian cookie shapes, and it has a unique crank handle that’s easy to operate. It’s a durable and highly rated option, but the design isn’t quite as easy to use as other cookie presses available. The Fante’s Easy Cookie Press is available at Amazon for $38.98.

Cuisinart CCP-10 Electric Cookie Press

The idea of an electric cookie press does sound great — after all, it can get tiring pressing the lever for dozens of cookies — and this Cuisinart model is definitely easy to use. All you have to do is press the button on the handle, and it pushes out dough to form a cookie. It comes with 12 cookie discs and eight piping tips, but if you only make spritz cookies once a year, the extra-high price point probably isn’t worth it. The ratings also aren’t the best, with some buyers noting that the quality isn’t as good as other Cuisinart gadgets they’ve tried. The Cuisinart CCP-10 Electric Cookie Press is available at Amazon for $149.20.

Masterclass Professional Icing Set

This Masterclass icing set includes 13 cookie discs and seven piping tips, along with a  storage case to hold all the accessories and the cookie press gun itself. It also works as an icing pipe! The trigger is adjustable, allowing you to choose how much dough comes out, but many people say it’s not as quality and is hard to clean. The Masterclass Professional Icing Set is available at Amazon for $49.11.

Why You Can Trust Me

Best cookie scoops
Credit: Two Peas and Their Pod

I am a self-proclaimed COOKIE MONSTER — in fact, I typically make them at least a few times a week! I’ve spent so much time baking all sorts of cookies, from classic Chocolate Chip Cookies to unique recipes like Oatmeal Zucchini Cookies, that I actually wrote a whole cookbook on them, which you can order NOW. 

After baking thousands of cookies in my career, I have a good idea of what works and what doesn’t. I have a lot of opinions about what baking tools deserve a spot in your kitchen, with cookie presses being a handy device for the yummiest spritz cookies. 

To find the best cookie press, I thought about what I liked in my Wilton cookie press. From there, I looked at a TON of popular options online from other brands that are recommended by cooking publications and customers. 

cookie press on baking sheet with spritz cookies.

What to Consider Before Buying a Cookie Press

Cookie presses are fairly simple devices, but there are a few features you may want to consider as you shop. 

Size and Material: These presses are often made from plastic, which is lightweight and inexpensive, but if you make cookies often, you may want to spend a little extra on an all-metal press, which will be more durable. Make sure to read through customer reviews to see if people had to toss the cookie press after a few uses, or if they’ve been using it for years.

Attachments: The other key feature to look for in a cookie press is its attachments. Most models come with 12 or more cookie discs, but they don’t always include the same set of shapes. If you want to make specific cookies, such as candy canes or reindeer, double-check that the press comes with the shape you want! 

Although spritz cookies are trendy for the holiday season, you can definitely make them year-round. Some options on my list include discs with other fun designs, so if you want to get the most bang for your buck by using it throughout all seasons, check out what shapes are included.

Storage: Because of the included discs, storing your cookie press can be tricky. If organization is a top priority, you can look for an option that comes with a sleeve or storage for the cookie gun and the discs. Otherwise, you may be stuck looking for that one Christmas tree design just a few days before the holiday. 

How Do You Use a Cookie Press?

To make spritz cookies, start by loading the desired disc into your cookie press with the smooth side facing out. Roll room-temperature cookie dough into a log shape, then load it into the barrel of your press. After inserting the plunger and screwing on the lid, you’ll want to press the trigger a few times to push the dough toward the bottom of the barrel. 

From here, it’s quick and easy to dispense cookies. Hold the press upright with the bottom resting on an ungreased cookie sheet. Squeeze the trigger to form a cookie, then lift up the press to release it onto the baking sheet. Just like that, you’ll have a spritz cookie. Repeat the process until your baking sheet is full, then put them in the oven to bake. 

Can You Make Spritz Cookies Without a Cookie Press?

It’s definitely possible to make spritz cookies without a cookie press. Using a pastry bag fitted with a large star piping tip, you may be able to recreate some of the classic cookie shapes like wreaths and cheese straws. This method is a bit more labor intensive, and the results probably won’t be as consistent, so I recommend getting one of the cookie presses on this list! 

Can You Use Sugar Cookie Dough in a Cookie Press?

Sugar cookie dough is generally too thick to be pushed through a cookie press. These tools are specifically designed to be used with spritz cookie dough, which is softer. In general, I don’t recommend putting other types of cookie dough into your cookie press, since you could break. 

Why Won’t My Spritz Cookies Won’t Release from the Press? 

The key to beautifully formed spritz cookies is having the dough at the proper temperature. If the dough is too thick or cold, you’ll have a hard time pushing it through the disc. On the other hand, if your dough is too warm, it will likely stick to the bottom of the press. Always follow the recipe directions for the cookie you’re making. It’s also important to dispense your dough directly onto a nonstick baking sheet — not onto parchment paper or a silicone mat — so the cookies have something to stick to. 

Best cookie presses
Credit: Two Peas and Their Pod

Spritz cookies are one of my favorites to make during the holidays, and that’s typically when my cookie press gets the most use. But there are plenty of other festive holiday cookies that you can make without a cookie press.

Here are some of my favorite cookie recipes for the winter season and beyond!

Find MORE cookie recipes HERE and in my cookie cookbook, Let’s Eat Cookies!

Prices were accurate at time of publication. 

Share this post on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *